I just wanted to make pumpkin bread. I didn’t think that was all that much to ask. But the first recipe I cooked, and virtually all the recipes I found online, called for copious amounts of oil. Which resulted in a heavy crumb and (natch) an oily flavor.
There are lots of lovely Pumpkin Bar recipes that don’t suffer these problems, but they are by nature very flaky and delicate — not suited for bread. I was really looking for something sturdy enough to ship out to CA to James’ mom and sister. Bars weren’t going to cut it.
I gave up on the internet and took inspiration from a longtime family favorite, which I knew to be freezable and shippable for the holidays: Triple Chocolate Cake, a mix-based pound cake recipe that includes pudding, mini chips, and (optionally) bourbon.
The 1.0 version of Pumpkin Crack was alcohol-free, because I didn’t have any in the house and couldn’t find anybody to borrow it from and it was late. It was still too heavy and gooey, although tasters agreed that it was amazing. (Except Cooper, who doesn’t like nuts, butterscotch, or bourbon.) Although later iterations did include alcohol, you can still make it alcohol-free by substituting more of any of the wet ingredients for the alcohol. More complicated discussion follows the recipe, but you can just go with the following and you’ll be fine.
Pumpkin Crack v 2.0:
1 spice cake mix
1 small box vanilla instant pudding
2 eggs and 3 egg whites
1/2 cup sour cream
1/2 cup bourbon
1 15-oz can pumpkin
1/2 cup butterscotch chips plus 1/2 cup pecans or walnut pieces, processed in a food processor until just chopped up
Mix all ingredients except butterscotch chips and nuts. Fold chips and nuts into batter.
Grease 2 9 x 5″ loaf pans and sprinkle liberally with cinnamon sugar. Divide batter between the two pans and sprinkle tops with cinnamon sugar.
Pour batter into pans and bake for 45 minutes in 357-degree oven (check periodically, b/c I was watching House and forgot to look at the time).
Cool on racks for 10 minutes before removing. You should really cool these completely before wrapping, to avoid a wet, gooey surface (thanks to Jeff at work for reminding me of that!).
Other thoughts:
*There was also 1/2 tsp almond extract in the one I did last night. I couldn’t really taste it but it may have been contributing a little something to the flavor.
*The butterscotch chips really want to turn to paste in the food processor. I am going to try freezing them first when I bake version 2.5. While I’m talking about the butterscotch, I should point out that the goal here was NOT to have it taste like butterscotch. In fact, people have some difficulty identifying it, which was my intent when I decided to grind them up a little. The chips, not the people.
*I wanted a little more of a bite from the bourbon flavor. For 2.5 I am going to use 1 cup bourbon and zero sour cream. I suspect you can use any combination of the two, as long as it totals 1 cup.
*If I don’t burn out (and I probably will), I may try this with yellow cake mix and some combination of pumpkin pie spices of my own creation.
Posted by themartyparty
Posted by themartyparty
Posted by themartyparty