Cheese Torta
My sister Allison requested this recipe, and I was so happy to be reminded of it!
This is a much-beloved savory cheese “spread” that is much more sophisticated than a typical cheese-cube offering without frightening guests who are put off by less-popular cheeses. The addition of other savory ingredients makes it an all-in-one-dish alternative to a proper cheese course.
The recipe was highly inspired by the one in Intimate Gatherings by Ellen Rose and Jessica Strand. I have made it many times, substituting cheeses I had on hand or that looked interesting in the store. For example, substituting shredded Gruyere or Jarlsberg for the blue cheese is a milder, yet pleasing option.
You can make one big cheese torta or multiple small ones. I find that the multiple small ones are so pretty and dainty, plus you can keep putting a fresh one out for longer-lasting events.
1 clove garlic, minced
½ bunch green onions, finely chopped (alternatively, you can use minced shallots)
1 stick unsalted butter at room temperature
4 oz Neufchatel cheese at room temperature
4 oz goat cheese crumbles
1 TB dry vermouth or white wine
1 cup crumbled blue cheese
½ cup chopped nuts, such as pistachios or walnuts
½ cup sundried tomatoes, soaked in hot water for 20 minutes, then drained and finely chopped
12 large basil leaves, finely chopped
3 basil tops (the top 4 leaves, still attached to each other) for garnish
In one bowl, combine the first 6 ingredients and mix well until a homogeneous mixture forms.
In another bowl combine the next 4 ingredients and toss well.
The construction method is the same whether you are making one large or multiple small tortas: line either a 2-cup bowl or mold OR about 3 smaller ramekins or teacups with plastic wrap, leaving a couple of inches of extra plastic wrap hanging over the edges. Place one of the basil tops in each small container OR multiple tops in the one bigger container, upside down. (When you unmold the cheese torta by flipping it over, this will be the presentation side – up.) Optionally, add a few whole nuts.
Place a layer of the blue cheese/tomato mixture in each container, then spread a layer of the Neufchatel mixture on top, being sure to spread it all the way to the edges.
Repeat with a second layer of blue cheese/ tomato, and then a second layer of Neufchatel. Gently tamp this down into the bowl or mold with the back of a spoon or a rubber spatula.
Cover with the excess plastic wrap and chill for several hours so the flavors can wed and the torta is firm.
Unmold by turning the torta(s) onto serving plates and removing the plastic wrap. Serve with crackers or unseasoned crostini.
My favorite containers to make these in are round-bottomed teacups. Using 3 of these gives you 3 pretty and accessible tortas. You can either go rustic and serve them on a small decorative cutting board, or go fancy and place them on small china serving plates.